
Community Engagement
Interviews with community members around the world who explained the system and their pathway

01
Mr. Robert Seltzer
What was your role at Wisconsin? He has 3 degrees from mich, Phd in psych and education, in college admissions since he was in graduate school in admissions, he moved from UMich to UW Madison where he was director of admissions, What is your role now? Associate at Florida Atlantic University What is holistic admissions? Is a term that has several connotations: you look at everything in the app, not just GPA and SAT/ACT. Look at personal statement, curriculum, and school they’re from. The reason holistic admission became popular was to get around race admissions restrictions, although less important these days. Now an Admissions Officer can only use race to explain the context of a student’s background. How heavily are standardized test scores weighted in the decision-making process? There was a time when he was new that many unis had a cutoff if you had an SAT score. if you had a high SAT nothing else mattered. In the last 5-10 years they have gone down in importance. There is research by college board that says when adding to GPA or Class Rank, they do slightly improve their ability to predict success in college. There was lot of schools put less emphasis on test scores now as there was a lot of political blowback that says certain populations do better on the test. Class rank gives a measure on how you relate to your peers. You are at least at the top of your peers. It depends a whole lot on the curriculum. Quality of curriculum has remained constant (12 ap classes was an easy admit for him. At that point test scores don’t matter. If you have 12 APs and get 3,4,5) Are there any common misconceptions about the admissions process that you'd like to clarify? He thinks that the public seems to think that there is more science and less art than the professional tends to think. He had a staff of 60 people to review apps and if they were to review the apps again they would get 80-90 percent consistency in the decisions. It is not a science there is no cutoff. The top and bottom are easy. In the middle is where they struggle, they may not have the space to admit a fully qualified candidate. However, there is a difference between qualified then there is a higher bar which is those who they admit at competitive institutions called admissible. Less so at Florida Atlantic University, a less selective university. The qualifications are vague and depend on the holistic process. He couldn’t just talk to someone for 5 minutes and tell if they are gonna get it due to the holistic process. Legacy importance?: Changing with the times, good institutions used to pay so much attention to legacy admissions. You try to give some bump to people with strong connections. The money that the parents/donors give is an important thing. He has turned down big donors who have donated buildings if the students aren’t competent. If they are at the qualified but not at the admissible the money would give a slight bump. 10 years ago it was more an effect, now it is less so. Have you seen a change in the quality of applicants themselves over the years? There has been grade inflation forever. What used to be a b+ average, now isn’t getting taken. B+ was the 80th percentile, now it’s the 50th. How has the common app changed how the admissions process works? Selectivity goes up as students apply to more schools. It is not wisconsin/michigans fault, they still fill their class. The number of applicants drive that. Common app doubled their applicant pool when they switched. Dramatically increase the number of applications without colleges changing anything. Is more applicants a good thing? The more applications, the more chances you have to get lucky. But it is just a waste of resources. It is a drag on the admissions office. There was a cascading effect on the waitlist due to the effect of over admittance. Final comments? As he was looking for colleges for his son, visiting any school he was thinking about attending, they visited Harvard and toured campus and thought the student attitude was off. You will see if you will fit in. You get a feel for the campus that you can’t get in the ranking. He also believes that if there was a study of students successful after college looking at the difference between those admitted to school x and attended vs admitted and chose not to attend. Those groups were equally successful whether they went to college or not. Finally, If you want to save money, start at a community college, a lot less expensive, after 2 years transfer then it starts to matter. No one looks at your first 2-years of college.
02
Student Interviews:
Jo (Korea) and Jerry (China)

Jo who is a high school student from Korea says: The College Admissions Test is the Suneung which tests Korean, English, Math, and two different subjects of your choice. 1st (best) to 9th grade (worst) is your test result and is compared to peers. It is given once per year at the same date and all seniors take it. This test establishes your future. However, even if you mess up the test you can re-take the test the following year. People prepare for the entire year as it is linked through every class. There also is stuff that is not taught in class which the government is criticized for. Everyone goes to an academy for a tutoring session. School ends at 3:30pm then they go straight to academy 3:30pm - 10 pm. 10 pm tutors must end by law but some disregard this illegally to make students study more. Korean government is trying to reduce the academies reliance but it does not work. Korean schools only have about 30 students per class In school everyone is given the same opportunities, at the academies it differs. Jerry who is a high school student from China says: He has a relative who took the gaokao 3 times, their scored got worse each time. She wanted to get into a better school but ended up gong to a worse art school. Every once in a while the government trys to stop them from tutoring due to lack of equity (monetary) but it never works. The Chinese government tries to make policy for only tutoring of 2 hrs per day but it is disregarded. Total of about 45-50 students per class in China. You are separated into different classes within grade level based on skill. You dont communicate with people from other classes within your grade. You get your class based on how you did in previous school/tests. Better classes have better teachers. In 5th grade, they have to prepare for middle school exams entrance exam (grade 7-9) Zhongkao, then there is a test for high school (10-12) Gaokao.

03
Mr. Georg Klein
Can you tell me about your educational journey, from primary school to secondary school and to where you are now? Mr. Klein went to primary school in 1976 in suburb of Munich for the first 4 four grades. After which, he had the decision between going to vocational education for more hands-on jobs or go to gymnasium. The fundemental decision between “high school” and gymnasium is a student’s grades by 4th grade. This grade distinction, however, is not strict. Even if you miss the benchmark grades you can proceed to gymnasium on a probationary base. For himself, he went to gymnasium. What made him choose the specific school? It is based on where you are living, the school district. Gymnasium is based on residency unless you are interested in a specific combination (i.e. learning Greek instead of Englsh) then you could transfer. He learned English and Latin. How did this gymnasium education work for you? In his education, there was a slightly different system where he could focus more on the Physics and business examinations in the last two years. The Bavarian school system has changed a bit in recent years. They try to strike a balance between prerequisites (German, math, social science) versus choosing your own courses/electives. The foundation is mandatory then there are more choices. What did you do after gymnasium? After, he went to mandatory work which is either military service or volunteering in social (elder care, church, etc.). They wanted to ensure Germany had enough armed forces. This lasted 12-18 months for everyone after high school education. Now it has ended but many people still choose a “social” year even after this was abolished, similar to a gap year. In ‘89 he graduated and studied business education. He studied at Augsburg and got his PhD degree. Flexibility in educational timeline: It previously took 13 years to graduate, now only 12 years to be more comparable to other European countries. This had some support but people were fighting against it due to the increased content per grade. They reversed the decisions back to 13 based on the opinion of parents with the option that if you are smart enough (willing to take extra classes) they could still complete it in 12 years to provide flexibility. What’s the process to get into university after gymnasium? Almost all universities are public universities and follow a specific selection system. The selection process is irrelevant to which school you came from so every location is equal. Grades matter. Since there are so many people they need to balance opportunity and demand. The better your grades are, the higher your probability of getting into your top college. But, everyone has a place. The universities have now been strengthened to pick and choose. Furthermore, they look more into the profile through interviews and other aspects, not just grades. For further education, It is pretty possible to get into master's and PhD programs. If you want to continue in an academic environment you could get paid PhD position or work as an external PhD student (paying your own means). About 80% were working internally, 20% external, maybe shifted now towards more external as many continue to work at a company while pursuing a PhD. Vocational education: The general position is that on one side it provides a great opportunity for those who don’t want a theoretical education and would prefer hands-on. They offer respected certifications such as “Meister” in carpentry, cutting hair, etc. If you achieve the level below Meister's degree you can work but not train others. The Meisters are the only ones who can train others. This distinction between trades-people gets a minimum quality for manufacturing. It is not just people from the street, these people are highly qualified, think of car manufacturing. We offer another path. And it provides a minimum qualtiy for the country. It is an excellent opportunity. He also mentioned the German phrase roughly translated to “the golden haniwork” as you can be extremely successful going down this route and running your own business. If you are offering good quality services you can very successful. Social status difference? If you are at a younger age you would rate the gymnasium path as more attractive but you still need someone to fix a broken pipe. There is a common agreement that the other path has a place in the entire society. The meister degree is seen as a pride for those who go down the vocational education path. People see the differenace as a carpenter is a master of wood while a university student could be a master of calculator, equally respected. Is it prevalent for adults to return to education later in life? There is a bifurcation early in life but if you really want ot you can go to the middle path until you get the necessary licenece to start studying originally. The Fahabitur gives the opportunity to study only limited to a specific topic/theme. If you really want to then there is an opportunity to work your way back to catch up. There is time to correct your path. However, people don’t really go back to university after entering the workforce, it is less prevalent to get an MBA for example as an adult than in the US. What is the Arbitur and how does it work? This is specific to the Arbitur in Bavaria. There is a mechanism that takes into your performance in your last two years and then there is a final examination (5 classes). Also some sort of project as well a part of the program. He thinks that there is not an extreme pressure in these exams. If you screw up it can affect but it is only a part of your performance as your scores have been building over multiple years. He wanted to note that the final years in German education is not commercialized by any means. If you have a neighbor who is good at math you can ask them for help but specialized tutoring services are not a thing in Germany. The final exam is centralized by the Bavarian ministry. This provides a minimum quality standard which contributes to the respect of the system. The grades in Bavaria may be lower than other German states due to this standardization, but universities look at where your arbitur grade was taken.
04
Mr. Lawrence Li

Can you tell me about your educational journey, from primary school to university to you job placement? The education philosophy between china and us is different. He was born in ‘71 still during cultural revolution. It felt like a production liine. Primary school there are not many choices, it is designated based on residence. High school is based on examination, like the sat. from primary school to middle he had testing on chinese, math, and english. The test was out of 300, if you reach 280 you got 1st category middle school 260 for 2nd catagory. For middle school 7-8 different academic courses in addition to chinese, math, english, you would have seminar/political, geography, biology, pe. Not dependant on interest, just general education. Need an exam to get into high school, the difference is that there are more courses. In addition to previous chinese, math, english PE, Political, Biological on the test on the high school enterance test. Then after high school they take the gaokao in June. Three day long test. (3+2) (chinese, english, math on one day) (political test) (then physics or chemistry) (kao means testing). The university you go to depends on score. If you are engineering, concept design, construction you would want to go to one of the major universities. If you don’t have a clear view of your plan you would want to go to a little bit of everything He experienced an opening up of china after the cultural revolution. English was a fashion, consulting and hotel management, you need to communicate with them. Fudan university in China, management + commercial english (commercial english is negotiation, news, economics in english) then worked in hotel industry. It was a new era, there was huge competition, interviews after interviews. Then he transferred to consulting CBRE real-estate, residential commercial and industrial. He mostly focused on commercial and industrial, site selection and negotiation. In getting his first interviews, the first thing they look at your education background some of your highschool but mostly your college: name of college, rank of college, and major. They don’t have gpa posted on resume, they just care about certificate/diploma. His time in college was not spent on projects, just classes. In the job they rotate you within the company to learn how each division works. In his memory the chinese education system is “just learn what the book says”, the test goes beyond or makes it more complicated. in the us it is like playing tennis with the teacher. In china, the teachers are always right, it it one-way. Like a baseball machine throwing the ball at you, it only goes one way. Tons of test practice and papers, people who apply to college lay out all of their textbooks and the height is like 1.5/1.6/1.7m high through all of the textbooks you need to go through. Now, they aren’t just looking at the gaokao, its skills/instruments, competitions done, but heavily related to academics. If your score isn’t that high then they really wont consider you. The skill is still a baseline. The educaiton mechanism hasn’t changed much in china. Outside of the Gaokao, you really can’t change your educational future. How is vocational education viewed in China? Vocational education is still viewed as a secondary consideration. They want to be proud of thei child, it is seen as a lower category. Some students retake the gaokao, but it does not happen a lot. Would have to go through the last year of high school again. A couple of his students went to the technical school, got some education, designated to a single area. It is a secondary school that is not college level, a skill school. Is it prevalent for adults to return to education later in life? Is online education prevalent and what are the outcomes if you know anyone who had used it? Online educaiton was famous in the 80’s, tv college, designated college in one of the channels danshi, then take the test and get diploma. After the cultural revolution people rushed to the gaokao. If they didn’t get goakao result, they want to tv college and it was recognized. Maybe lasted 10 years. Some adults go back to educaiton later in life, but mostly for MBA to refine their educaiton background. (join-venture MBA Washu, NYU, Duke) Anything else? During the process before highschool, in grade 3 (6 years primary, 3 years middle, 3 years high, 4 years college) there was a lecture from teacher saying that “this test impacts your future”. He had the same speech each time after. College -> better life; no college -> 2nd or 3rd catagories